Last updateTue, 26 May 2020 7pm

A Chilling Effect

13 sum water fig1Figure 1. A three-dimensional map of the Enwave system laying pipeWhile the Canadian winter sees a sizeable portion of the population scurrying to points south, those bone-chilling temperatures left behind will eventually provide relief in Toronto during the humid, hot summer months. This is because of a phenomenon that occurs with Lake Ontario.


During the chilly months, the surface of Lake Ontario cools to about 39°F (4°C), which means the water is denser and sinks to the lake’s bottom. In summertime, the surface water heats up, but that water remains on the surface because it is not dense enough to sink. However, no matter how hot the ambient temperature during the summer, the deeper water remains very cold. This creates a permanent reservoir of cold water on the bottom of Lake Ontario that can be used for cooling.


12 sum water backflowBack flow preventerTAPPING INTO THE SOURCE

To use the renewable energy of this cold water, Enwave Energy Corporation created Deep Lake Water Cooling (DLWC), the world’s largest lake-source cooling system. For this article, Alex Sotirov, Enwave Energy Corporation’s vice president of engineering, provided details that describe the system he helped design and install and how that system works.

Three 63-inch high-density polyethylene (HDPE) pipes are installed along the natural slope of the lake bottom to pump water from a depth of 273 feet (83 meters) to the Toronto Island Filtration Plant, which is 3.1 miles (5 km) away (Figure 1). Because this water ultimately ends up in the city’s potable water system, the pipes and valves with which it comes into contact are specified food grade. Enwave uses American Water Works Association standard valves.

13 sum water fig2Figure 2. Deep lake water cooling system schematic

At the intake, 52-inch carbon steel butterfly valves direct the cold water to Enwave’s energy transfer station at the city’s John Street pumping station. These valves were chosen because they take up less space, are lighter than gate valves, and have packing and seating designed to last 80 years.

12 sum water pipe gallery1Energy transfer station pipe gallery At this stage, heat exchangers facilitate an energy transfer between the cold lake water and Enwave’s closed chilled-water supply loop (Figure 2). At the time it was built, the DLWC project had the largest set of heat exchangers ever specified in Canada.

The closed loop contains supply and return pipes running in a tunnel built specifically for this purpose.

About 7.5 miles (12 km) of underground pipe has been installed beneath the city’s core to serve as a distribution network. The loop runs from Simcoe Street near Lake Ontario north through the financial and hospital districts to Queen’s Park and back to where the pipe system begins. The downtown closed loop is made of steel and HDPE and contains over six million gallons of water. The flow rate through the system peaks at over 72,000 gallons per minute (gpm) and averages over 30,000 gpm.

A back-up system for the city’s closed loop has been constructed for situations such as high heat days: 14,000 tons of additional back-up cooling can be provided by two steam-powered centrifugal chillers and two traditional electric centrifugal chillers. In routine circumstances, the heat from the loop is removed using lake water alone and what flows through the downtown loop will bypass the four supplemental chillers.

For use here, there are full bore, 48-inch ball valves handling pressures of 120 psi. By using specialized access points, maintenance crews can test the valves, and adjust and replace seating and packing without removing the valves.

The chilled water passes from the main Enwave system into each building’s cooling system via a two-position, motorized butterfly valve that sends it to a metering system and then through a series of control, isolation and balancing valves to the building’s system.

13 sum water heat exchangersHeat exchangers, which provide the way for energy transfer between the cold lake water and the closed chilled-water supply loopOnce inside a building, flow of the chilled water to the building’s exchange system is controlled by a manual isolation valve. The water is pumped directly to the building’s heat exchanger where it chills the building’s closed loop system. The chilling water is then pumped back to the Enwave system through a motorized two-position valve and a balancing valve to a temperature sensor. Once past the sensor, the water goes back out to the main system through a modulating two-way control valve.

After conveying its energy to the building’s internal system, the Enwave chilled water continues its journey through the system. Meanwhile, each building’s internal closed loop system uses thousands of valves, including manual isolation and ball valves, to convey chilled water to individual offices. As new customers want to go online or as new skyscrapers are built, the system can accommodate needs simply by drilling from the basement of a new building into the Enwave dedicated tunnel.

But what happens to the lake water itself, many wonder. The answer is that it has never mingled with the Enwave system; only its energy has been conveyed to the closed system.


The benefits of the system are numerous. Building owners appreciate it because Lake Ontario serves as the engine of cooling, eliminating the need for electrically powered chillers. This frees up significant square footage and reduces maintenance costs for retrofits at existing buildings. It also saves hundreds of thousands of dollars in capital investments at new construction.

13 sum water cooling deployedDeep Lake Water Cooling pipe deployment Additionally, when combined on average, the buildings that use this system instead of using individual chiller packages free up 61 megawatts of power on the Toronto electric grid. Because less electricity is required to power individual air-conditioning installations, less fuel is required for consumption at local utility plants. The corresponding carbon dioxide (CO2) gas emission reductions are figured to be about 87,000 tons annually, the equivalent of about 16,000 automobiles on the nation’s roadways.

The DLWC also reduces the need for hydrochloroflourocarbon- and chlorofluorocarbon-based refrigerants. And, even though the water running through the system warms up about 2°F (less than 1°C), when it enters the city’s potable water system, minimal heat returns into the lake, and no extra water has been used to accommodate the system.

Like any project, this system is ultimately dependent on the components of which it is comprised. For that reason, high-quality valves designed to last decades are key to ensuring its continued reliable service.


Kate Kunkel is senior editor of VALVE Magazine. Reach her at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..


VALVE Magazine Print & Digital


• Print magazine
Digital magazine
• VALVE eNews
Read the latest issue

*to qualified valve professionals in the U.S./Canada

Looking for a career in the Valve Industry?

ValveCareers Horiz

To learn more, visit the Valve Careers YouTube channel to watch the videos below or visit ValveCareers.com a special initiative of the Valve Manufacturers Association

  • Latest Post

  • Popular

  • Links

  • Events

New Products